MemberSpace

The Substack alternative for your own website

Your paid newsletter, your brand, your readers.

Substack keeps 10% of every paid subscription. MemberSpace puts your paid newsletter on your own website, with lower fees and room to grow into community and courses.

Any website works. Free for 7 days.

  • 4.7 on G2
  • 4.9 on Capterra
  • 4.8 on Trustpilot
A members-only content library on a writer's own website, an alternative to Substack

$350 million

earned by customers using MemberSpace

20,000+ customers served Est. 2015

Entrepreneurs, creators and businesses manage paid communities, courses and content on their own websites with MemberSpace.

  • 4.7 / 5 on G2
  • 4.9 / 5 on Capterra
  • 4.8 / 5 on Trustpilot
Read MemberSpace reviews

Why writers switch from Substack

Substack makes it easy to start a paid newsletter. But when writers look for a Substack alternative, the same few frustrations keep coming up.

  1. A 10% cut of every subscription

    With Substack Substack keeps 10% of paid subscriptions, plus card fees, for as long as you publish there.

    MemberSpace MemberSpace takes 5% on Starter and 2% on Growth. See pricing.

  2. Followers don't come with you

    With Substack Writers can export subscribers, but not their Substack followers or readers who pay through the iPhone app.

    MemberSpace Readers join and pay on your own website, so every member relationship stays yours.

  3. Every publication looks alike

    With Substack Reviewers say design and branding options are limited, so it's hard to make your publication look like you.

    MemberSpace Your newsletter lives inside your own site design, built with the website builder you already love.

  4. Substack's brand comes first

    With Substack Critics say Substack puts its own app, social feed and branding ahead of the writers who publish there.

    MemberSpace Readers come back to your website every time, and you can add community forums, courses and coaching too.

Based on substack.com, public reviews on G2 and TechRadar, and The Verge's May 2026 reporting, checked October 2026.

Any website works. Free for 7 days.

More than a newsletter

Give your readers a community, right on your website

Community forums

A community forum that lives on your website

Members post, comment and get to know each other without ever leaving your site. Every conversation builds your brand and your website, not a third‑party platform.

  • Posts, comments and emoji reactions
  • Threaded replies for side conversations
  • Follow any discussion for real‑time notifications
  • Free or paid community spaces, as many as you need
  • Search, bookmarks and new‑post alerts
Explore community features
Community discussion thread on a creator's own website, a Substack alternative

Your brand

Grow your brand, not someone else's platform

Your membership sits inside the website you've already designed. Members join in one click, pay in one tap, and come back to your site every time.

  • One-click sign-up and login with Google
  • Apple Pay and Google Pay checkout
  • Free trials and manual approval
  • Sell the same content across different plans
See every feature
Member sign-up with Google on a yoga website, part of switching from Substack to MemberSpace

MemberSpace vs. Substack, side by side

Both help you earn from paying readers. Here's where they're different.

Feature MemberSpace Substack
Where your readers join On your own website On Substack's site and app
Fee on paid subscriptions 5% Starter, 2% Growth 10%
Monthly software price From $39/mo $0
Your own domain Your website's domain $50 one-time fee
Paid newsletters

Substack details from substack.com/going-paid and Substack's custom domain announcement, checked October 2026.

Any website works. Free for 7 days.

What Substack's 10% really costs you

Substack is free to start, but its cut grows with every new subscriber. Here's a year of newsletter income on each platform.

Earning $2,000 a month

MemberSpace Starter

$1,668 /year

  • Starter plan, $39/mo $468
  • 5% fee on $24,000 $1,200

Substack

$2,400 /year

  • 10% fee on $24,000 $2,400

Save $732 a year compared with Substack

Earning $5,000 a month

MemberSpace Growth

$2,388 /year

  • Growth plan, $99/mo $1,188
  • 2% fee on $60,000 $1,200

Substack

$6,000 /year

  • 10% fee on $60,000 $6,000

Save $3,612 a year compared with Substack

MemberSpace prices billed annually, from this site's pricing page in October 2026. Substack's 10% fee from substack.com/going-paid, checked October 2026. Both before payment processing fees.

Everything beyond the newsletter

Substack is built around posts and email. MemberSpace gives you the flexibility to sell newsletters, community, courses and coaching, all on your own website.

Online courses

Courses your way

Build courses however you like. Members get new-lesson alerts and can search and bookmark anything.

Online courses
Online cooking course lesson on a creator's website, a Substack alternative feature

Content library

A library members love to dig into

Lesson plans, videos, downloads and more, with search, bookmarks and new-content alerts built in.

Content library
Members-only content library of teaching resources, an alternative to Substack
  • Courses

    Sell online courses your way, with new-lesson alerts, search and bookmarks for members.

    Online courses
  • Newsletters

    Put a paywall around your blog or newsletter, and email members with built‑in Member Messages.

    Paid newsletters
  • Coaching

    Sell coaching programs and client-only resources straight from your own website.

    Sell coaching
  • Gated files

    Protect downloads like ebooks, templates and worksheets so only members can get them.

    Digital downloads

Any website works. Free for 7 days.

Human support and growth help

Real people, every single week

Switching platforms is a big decision, so you shouldn't have to figure it out alone. Every MemberSpace plan comes with real human help, plus weekly sessions to grow your membership business.

  • Email and 1:1 Zoom help from the MemberSpace team
  • Free weekly Live Support Hours for setup questions
  • Weekly Membership Business Coaching for sales, marketing and launches
  • Free member migrations, handled by our team
MemberSpace live support video call, real human help when you switch from Substack

Moving from Substack is easier than you think

Our team moves your members over for free, so you can switch without starting from scratch.

  1. Share your member list

    Fill in the spreadsheet our support team sends you.

  2. Keep or restart billing

    Keep members' current billing dates, or start fresh cycles.

  3. We import your members

    Each member gets an invite to activate their membership.

Switching from Substack: common questions

Can I run a paid newsletter on my own website instead of Substack?

Yes. MemberSpace adds a paid newsletter paywall to your own website, and you can email members with built‑in Member Messages.

Is MemberSpace cheaper than Substack?

Once you earn more than about $780 a month, yes. Substack keeps 10% of paid subscriptions, while MemberSpace charges $39/mo plus 5% on Starter, or $99/mo plus 2% on Growth. See all plans.

Can I move my members from Substack to MemberSpace?

Yes, and it's free on any paid plan. Our team imports your members from a simple spreadsheet, and each member gets an invite to activate their account. If you have Stripe customer IDs, we can sync payment details so members don't re-enter them. Learn about migrations.

Does MemberSpace work with my website?

Almost certainly. MemberSpace works with Squarespace, Wix, Showit, Webflow, WordPress, Duda, Notion and any other website builder. Setup takes a few minutes.

Can I sell more than one kind of product?

Yes. Sell online courses, a content library, community forums, paid newsletters, coaching and gated downloads, separately or bundled into membership plans.

Bring your members home

Give your members one place to learn, talk and belong: your website.

Try for free

Any website works. Free for 7 days.