how to increase member pricing on squarespace

How to Increase Member Pricing on Squarespace

If you’re running a membership on Squarespace and want to raise your prices, you’ve probably realized something frustrating:

You can’t update pricing for your existing members.

Squarespace only lets you change pricing for new customers. Anyone already subscribed stays locked into their original plan and price.

So if you want to increase your membership from $10/month to $15/month, your only real option is:

  • Ask members to cancel
  • And re-subscribe at the new price

Which… most people won’t do. In this post, we’ll talk about the only way to update pricing for members on Squarespace, and it’s surprisingly super easy!

Get more membership features on Squarespace!

The easiest way to accept membership payments or one-time charges for digital products like online courses, communities, content libraries, and more — all from your own website!

Get started for free! 5 minutes to set up.

Why You Can’t Update Pricing for Existing Members on Squarespace

This is just a limitation of how Squarespace Member Sites works.

There’s no built-in way to:

  • Update pricing for current subscribers
  • Move members from one plan to another
  • Apply pricing changes across your existing member base

So over time, you end up with:

  • Old members paying one price
  • New members paying another
  • A messy, inconsistent pricing structure

And more importantly—you’re leaving revenue on the table.

The Only Way to Increase Membership Pricing on Squarespace

If you want to actually change pricing for existing members, you need a system that supports it.

MemberSpace is a plugin that connects to your Squarespace site and allows you to migrate existing members to a new pricing plan.

Instead of forcing members to cancel and rejoin, you can move them over seamlessly.

increasing member pricing on squarespace

How MemberSpace Helps You Update Member Pricing

With MemberSpace, increasing your pricing is done through a pricing migration.

Here’s how it works:

  1. Create your new pricing plan
  2. Disable the old plan so no new members join it
  3. Request a migration to move existing members
  4. Choose how you want the change applied:
    • Immediately (with proration)
    • Or at the next billing cycle

Once that’s set, MemberSpace will:

  • Move your members to the new plan
  • Handle billing updates automatically
  • Apply prorated charges or credits if needed

No manual updates. No awkward re-signup process.

Example: Increasing Membership Pricing

Let’s say:

  • You currently charge $10/month
  • You’ve added more content and want to increase it to $15/month

With MemberSpace, you can:

  • Create a new $15/month plan
  • Migrate your existing members to it
  • Choose whether the change happens now or at their next billing date

If it happens mid-cycle, MemberSpace automatically calculates:

  • What they’ve already paid
  • What they owe moving forward

Everything is handled behind the scenes.

Why This Matters for Growing Your Membership

At some point, every membership business needs to adjust pricing.

Maybe you:

  • Add more value
  • Expand your content library
  • Introduce new features

If you can’t update pricing for existing members, you’re stuck with outdated rates forever.

With the ability to migrate members to new pricing, you can:

  • Keep your pricing consistent
  • Increase revenue as your business grows
  • Avoid confusing or frustrating your members

FAQs About Increasing Membership Pricing on Squarespace

Can I increase membership prices for existing members on Squarespace?

No. Squarespace only allows pricing changes for new customers. Existing members stay on their original pricing.

How do I change pricing for current subscribers on Squarespace?

There’s no native way to do this. The only workaround is asking members to cancel and re-subscribe, which can lead to lost customers.

What is the best way to increase membership pricing without losing members?

The best approach is to use a tool like MemberSpace, which allows you to migrate existing members to a new pricing plan without requiring them to take action.

What happens when pricing changes mid-billing cycle?

With MemberSpace, pricing changes can be prorated automatically. Members are charged or credited based on the time remaining in their billing cycle.

Do members need to re-subscribe when pricing changes?

With Squarespace, yes. With MemberSpace, no—members can be migrated to a new plan without canceling.

Does MemberSpace work with Squarespace?

Yes. MemberSpace integrates directly with Squarespace and adds advanced membership features like pricing migrations and flexible billing.

Final Thoughts

Squarespace doesn’t support:

  • Updating pricing for existing members
  • Moving members between plans
  • Applying pricing changes at scale

If you want to raise your prices without breaking your membership experience:

MemberSpace gives you a way to migrate members to new pricing smoothly and automatically.

Get more membership features on Squarespace!

The easiest way to accept membership payments or one-time charges for digital products like online courses, communities, content libraries, and more — all from your own website!

Get started for free! 5 minutes to set up.